Exploring the Pros and Cons of Standalone and Tethered Mixed Reality Devices: Which One is Right for You?

Mixed reality technology has been advancing rapidly in recent years, and one of the key decisions that buyers need to make when choosing a device is whether to go for a standalone or tethered option. Both have their advantages and disadvantages, and the choice will largely depend on individual preferences and use cases. In this article, we’ll delve into the world of mixed reality devices, exploring the differences between standalone and tethered options and discussing the various uses and benefits of each.

Mixed Reality (MR) devices can be divided into two main categories: standalone and tethered.

Standalone MR Devices

Standalone MR devices are self-contained headsets that do not require a connection to a separate computer or console to function. These devices typically have their own processors, sensors, and batteries, and are designed to provide a fully immersive MR experience without any additional hardware.

Standalone MR devices are ideal for users who want a more convenient and portable MR experience, as they allow for more freedom of movement and can be used in a variety of settings without requiring additional hardware. They are also typically more user-friendly than tethered devices, as they require less setup and configuration.

Examples of standalone MR devices

Microsoft HoloLens

A self-contained MR headset that allows users to interact with digital content overlaid onto the real world. The HoloLens uses advanced sensors and cameras to track the user’s movements and the environment, providing a seamless and interactive MR experience.

Magic Leap One

Another MR headset that uses advanced optics and sensors to create a realistic and immersive mixed reality experience. The Magic Leap One allows users to interact with virtual objects and characters overlaid onto the real world, making it a popular choice for gaming, entertainment, and educational applications.

Nreal Light

A lightweight MR headset that is designed for consumer use, offering a more affordable and accessible MR experience. The Nreal Light is compatible with a wide range of devices, including smartphones and PCs, and allows users to interact with virtual content overlaid onto the real world.

Oculus Quest 2

This is a popular standalone VR headset that also supports MR applications. It uses advanced tracking and processing technology to provide a fully immersive VR experience, and can also be used for MR applications that overlay virtual content onto the real world.

Varjo XR-3

This is a high-end MR headset that is designed for professional and enterprise applications. It offers a high-resolution display and advanced tracking capabilities, making it ideal for use in industries such as architecture, engineering, and design.

Overall, standalone MR devices are becoming increasingly popular and are opening up new opportunities for innovation and growth across many different industries, from entertainment and gaming to healthcare and education.

Advantages of Standalone MR Devices

1. Portability and convenience

Standalone MR devices do not require a separate computer or console to function, making them more portable and user-friendly.

2. Easy setup

Standalone MR devices are generally easier to set up and use compared to tethered devices.

3. Lower cost

Standalone MR devices are generally less expensive than tethered devices.

Disadvantages of Standalone MR Devices

1. Less processing power

Standalone MR devices have less processing power than tethered devices, which can limit their performance and the quality of the MR experience.

2. Limited battery life

Standalone MR devices rely on battery power, which can limit the amount of time that they can be used without recharging.

3. Limited features

Standalone MR devices may have fewer features and less advanced tracking capabilities than tethered devices.

Tethered MR Devices

Tethered MR devices are MR headsets that require a connection to a separate computer or console to function. They typically consist of a headset with sensors and a display, and a separate computer or console that provides the processing power and graphics rendering necessary for the MR experience.

Tethered MR devices are typically more powerful than standalone devices, as they can leverage the processing power of the connected computer or console to deliver more advanced graphics and a more immersive MR experience. However, they are less portable and less convenient to use than standalone devices, as they require additional hardware and are generally less user-friendly.

Examples of Tethered MR Devices

HTC Vive Pro

This is a high-end MR headset that requires a connection to a powerful gaming PC to function. It offers a fully immersive MR experience with advanced tracking and graphics capabilities.

Oculus Rift S

This is a popular MR headset that requires a connection to a gaming PC. The Rift S offers a high-quality MR experience with advanced graphics and tracking capabilities.

Windows Mixed Reality headsets

These are a range of MR headsets from different manufacturers, including HP, Dell, and Acer. They require a connection to a PC running Windows 10 and offer a range of MR experiences with varying levels of quality and immersion.

Varjo XR-1 Developer Edition

This is a high-end MR headset that requires a connection to a powerful PC to function. It offers advanced tracking and graphics capabilities, making it ideal for professional and enterprise applications.

Meta 2

This is an MR headset that requires a connection to a powerful computer to function. It offers a high-resolution display and advanced tracking capabilities, making it ideal for use in industrial and enterprise applications.

Tethered MR devices are generally more powerful and offer a more immersive MR experience than standalone devices, but they require a separate computer or console to function, making them less portable and less convenient to use.

Advantages of Tethered MR Devices

1. More processing power

Tethered MR devices have more processing power than standalone devices, which can provide a more immersive and high-quality MR experience.

2. Advanced features

Tethered MR devices often have more advanced tracking capabilities and other features, such as hand controllers, that can enhance the MR experience.

3. Higher image quality

Tethered MR devices often have higher-resolution displays and better graphics performance, which can provide a more immersive and realistic MR experience.

Disadvantages of Tethered MR Devices

1. Less portability

Tethered MR devices require a separate computer or console to function, which makes them less portable and more difficult to set up.

2. Higher cost

Tethered MR devices are generally more expensive than standalone devices, as they require a separate computer or console and may have higher-end features.

3. More complex setup

Tethered MR devices can be more complex to set up and use compared to standalone devices, which may require more technical expertise.

Where can the Standalone and Tethered MR Devices be used?

Standalone

a) Gaming

Standalone MR devices such as the Oculus Quest and the HTC Vive Focus are popular for gaming, as they provide an immersive and portable gaming experience.

b) Education and Training

Standalone MR devices can be used in education and training, for example, to provide hands-on learning experiences in virtual environments.

c)Social Media

Tethered MR devices often have higher-resolution displays and better graphics performance, which can provide a more immersive and realistic MR experience.

d) Travel and Tourism

Standalone MR devices can be used to provide virtual tours of tourist destinations, museums, and other places of interest.

Tethered

a) Enterprise Applications

Tethered MR devices such as the HoloLens 2 and the Magic Leap One are popular for enterprise applications, such as training, design, and visualization.

b) Medical Applications

Tethered MR devices can be used in medical applications, for example, to provide training for medical procedures or to assist with surgical planning.

c) Engineering and Design

Tethered MR devices can be used in engineering and design applications, for example, to visualize and manipulate 3D models in a virtual environment.

d) Research and Development

Tethered MR devices can be used in research and development, for example, to simulate and test new products or processes.

Overall, both standalone and tethered MR devices have a wide range of uses across various industries, and the choice between them depends on the specific needs and requirements of the user.

More to explore

UX|UI Design

I bring products from idea to development using a User Center Design approach.

See my work

UX Audits

I help businesses improve their products usability and performance with a UX Audit.

How it works

Website Development

I build websites using WordPress/Webflow for small businesses and bloggers.

How I help

Andrea Viflor | User Experience Designer